The move we see most often is from Xero to Business Central, and the conversation usually starts the same way: the finance manager has hit a wall (multi-company, stock, purchase orders, something), the partner has shown a demo, and everyone is excited. Nobody has said what gets worse. Something always does. Here is the honest version.
What you gain
- One system for the whole business. Xero is a ledger with invoicing. Business Central is the ledger plus sales orders, purchase orders, stock, warehousing, manufacturing, projects, service and fixed assets on one database. The spreadsheet that currently lives between Xero and the warehouse goes away.
- Proper purchasing. Purchase orders, goods receipt, three-way matching, approvals. Xero's bills are an after-the-fact record; Business Central's purchase ledger controls spend before it happens.
- Stock that is actually right. Item ledger, costing (FIFO, average, standard), locations, bins, lots and serials, assembly and manufacturing. Xero's tracked inventory is fine for a few hundred SKUs with no complexity. Past that it is a liability.
- Multi-company and intercompany. Separate companies on one database, intercompany postings, consolidation with eliminations. In Xero this is separate subscriptions and a spreadsheet.
- Dimensions. Tag every transaction with department, cost centre, project, region, whatever you like, and report on any combination. Xero's two tracking categories are the single most common reason businesses leave.
- Control. Posting periods you can lock, approval workflows, audit trail on everything, permissions down to the field, a change log. Auditors and investors notice.
- Headroom. The same product runs at ten users and at three hundred, in one country or twenty. You will not do this again in three years.
- The Microsoft stack. Excel that reads and writes the ledger, Outlook that shows the customer's balance, Teams, Power BI, Copilot. If the business already lives in Microsoft 365, this matters more than any feature.
What you lose
- Simplicity. Xero is designed so that a business owner can do the books on a Sunday evening. Business Central is designed so that a finance team can run a company. Posting a sales invoice in Xero is one screen; in Business Central it is a sales invoice with posting groups behind it. That is the price of control, and it is a real price for a small team.
- The bank feed experience. Business Central has bank feeds and good reconciliation (now with Copilot matching), but Xero's is the best in the market and you will miss it for a month.
- Your accountant's familiarity. Most UK accountancy practices live in Xero. Yours will either learn Business Central (the good ones already have), take exports, or charge you more. Have the conversation before you sign.
- The app ecosystem's convenience. Xero's marketplace is full of two-click integrations. Business Central's AppSource is large and growing, and the standard APIs mean anything can be connected, but it is a connection someone sets up, not a toggle.
- Cost. Xero is tens of pounds a month. Business Central Essentials is £61.50 per full user per month on UK list price, Premium £84.60, Team Members £6.20, plus an implementation that is a project with a budget. The licensing calculator gives the licence number in a minute; the implementation is typically a multiple of the first year's licences for a small business.
- Speed of setup. Xero: an afternoon. Business Central: eight to sixteen weeks for a straightforward business, because it is being configured to how the business works rather than the other way round.
How to tell you are ready
You are ready to leave Xero when at least three of these are true: you have more than one company and consolidate by hand; you need purchase orders and goods receipt; stock is wrong and it costs you; the two tracking categories are not enough; month-end is mostly spreadsheets; you have more than about eight people who need to be in the system; investors, a bank or a buyer are asking questions about controls; or you have just won a contract the current system cannot support.
You are not ready, and should stay on Xero for now, if you are a single company with simple or no stock, fewer than ten users, and the pain is really about one report or one process. Fix that in Xero or with an add-on. We will tell you that honestly, because a business that moves too early is an unhappy customer.
What the migration involves
Xero to Business Central is a well-trodden path and it follows the pattern in our data migration piece: customers, suppliers and items cleaned in Xero; the chart of accounts redesigned rather than copied (this is your one chance); opening balances and open items at a period end; two years of monthly balances for comparatives; Xero kept read-only for history. Eight to sixteen weeks from kick-off, with a go-live on the first day of a month, and a finance team that spends the first month-end slightly cross and the second one wondering how they ever managed. The migration page has the detail and a fixed-scope offer for straightforward businesses.
Talk to usWant this done in your Business Central?
More from the blog
